The comparison between a claymore and a broadsword in terms of which one is "better" is subjective and depends on various factors, including the specific criteria, combat style, and intended use. Here are some considerations:

1. Size and Length: The claymore is typically larger and longer than a broadsword. It has a two-handed grip and a longer blade, which can provide extended reach and potentially greater striking power. The larger size of the claymore can be advantageous in certain combat scenarios, such as facing multiple opponents or engaging enemies from a distance.
2. Handling and Maneuverability: Due to its larger size and weight, the claymore can require more strength and control to wield effectively. It may be less maneuverable compared to a broadsword, which is generally smaller and lighter. A broadsword may offer greater agility and versatility in quick strikes and rapid changes of direction.
3. Blade Design and Purpose: The blade design of a claymore typically features a straight, double-edged blade with a crossguard, while a broadsword generally has a slightly curved, single or double-edged blade. The specific design can impact factors such as cutting ability, thrusting capability, and defensive maneuvers. The purpose of the sword, combat style, and personal preference can also influence the effectiveness of the blade design.
4. Combat Style and Tactics: The claymore, with its larger size and longer reach, is often associated with powerful, sweeping strikes and wide arcs. It can be effective in open-field battles or against opponents in heavy armor. A broadsword, due to its smaller size and maneuverability, may be more suitable for close-quarters combat, parrying, and quick, agile movements.
5. Historical Context and Cultural Significance: The claymore is historically associated with Scottish warriors, while the term "broadsword" can encompass a range of swords used in different cultures and time periods. The historical context and cultural significance of these swords can influence preferences and perceptions of value.

Ultimately, determining which sword is "better" depends on the specific criteria, intended use, combat style, and personal preferences. Both the claymore and the broadsword have their own merits and intended uses. It is essential to consider factors such as individual skill, historical context, combat requirements, and personal preferences when comparing these swords.